Verified Document

Condition That's Necessary For An Argument To Term Paper

¶ … condition that's NECESSARY for an argument to be "fallacious." necessary condition for an argument to be fallacious is that it be an argument (rather than, say, a mere description). Nothing is a fallacious argument unless it is an argument. For 5 points, cite one condition that's SUFFICIENT.

A sufficient condition for an argument to be fallacious is if the argument trades on an ambiguity and thereby commits the fallacy of equivocation. An argument commits the fallacy of equivocation if (but not only if) two premises of the argument contain a predicate that has two different senses. If we disambiguate the premises in the same way, one of the premises is false. If we disambiguate the premises so as to make them both true, the argument is invalid.

For 5 points, cite one condition that's both NECESSARY AND SUFFICIENT.

Being rationally unconvincing is both necessary and sufficient for an argument to be fallacious. An argument is rationally unconvincing if and only if (1) the premises don't support the conclusion, (2) one of the premises is false, or (3) the argument is circular (or begs-the-question).

1.4. Cite one RELEVANT condition that's neither necessary nor sufficient:

When evaluating an argument to see whether it is fallacious, it is relevant to check to see whether it is deductively valid -- that is, check to see if it is not possible for the premises to be true and the conclusion false. All non-fallacious (rationally compelling) arguments are either deductively valid or inductively strong. Being invalid is not a necessary condition for fallaciousness, though, as some valid arguments are fallacious -- those with false premises and circular arguments. Moreover,...

Find an example in of such an argument IN THE TEXT and show how it fits your portrayal.
The fallacy of ambiguity -- discussed in Rudinow, et al. Chapter 3, Section 4 -- illustrates this well.

Hurley provides an answer to the problem of establishing relevance in inductive arguments. Check Chapter 9!

2.1. For 5 points, where exactly is it located? Quote the relevant sentence(s) and give the requisite citation. Be as brief as possible:

in her introduction to Induction.

2.2. For 0-20 points, write an essay 1 page giving your opinion as to how this process might be encouraged and supported.

See below: Essay I

Rudinow and Barry provide an answer to the problem of establishing relevance in inductive arguments.

1. For 5 points, where exactly is it located? Quote the relevant sentence(s) and give the requisite citation. Be as brief as possible:

The start of chapter 7 on induction.

2. For 0-20 points, write an essay 1 page giving your opinion as to how this process might be encouraged and supported.

See below: Essay II

Essay I. Sometimes it is difficult to see whether an argument contains premises that are relevant to the conclusion. There are lots of reasons for this. For example, the fact that we find the fallacies of relevance psychologically compelling, on the one hand, and often are unconvinced by arguments that are invalid buy would become valid with the addition of a plausible implicit premise, illustrate that we have…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Argumentative Essay for College Athletes Getting Vaccinated
Words: 3964 Length: 13 Document Type: Argumentative Essay

COVID-19 VACCINATIONThe NCAA should make the Covid-19 vaccination mandatory because this vaccine brings plenty of benefits to sport programs and to the athletes competing themselves. These benefits range from economic advantages that help support academic institutions to intangible benefits designed to help society cope with the devastation caused by the COVID-19 pandemic.The recent COVID-19 pandemic has caused unprecedented damage to countries around the world.. The sudden halt of economic activity

Should Someone With a Pre-Existing Condition Be Denied Health Insurance...
Words: 2741 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

Pre-Existing Condition and Denial of Health Insurance The focus of this work in writing is to examine whether the individual with a pre-existing health condition should be denied health insurance coverage. Toward this end, this work will examine the literature in this area of study. A pre-existing condition is "a medical condition that existed before someone applies for or enrolls in a new health insurance policy. It can be something as

Pascal's Gamble the Human Condition Is One
Words: 2029 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Pascal's Gamble The human condition is one of suffering and redemption. One who does not suffer is not human. Death and the withering away of youth and vitality explicitly demonstrates the entropic nature of existence. This situation is problematic for the rationale mind. No universally accepted system of navigating the death sentence, known has human existence, has sufficiently explained the quandary. Blaise Pascal, the renowned 17th century mathematician and philosopher, in

Global Warming Argument Fact or Fallacy Critical
Words: 2496 Length: 9 Document Type: Essay

Global Warming Argument FACT OR FALLACY Critical Thinking World Health Organization (2013) reports that, in the last century, the earth's warmth increased by approximately 0.75 degrees C. And further at more than 0.18 degrees every decade in the last 25 years. This phenomenon, called global warming, is said to result from the greenhouse effect whereby deleterious gases, such as carbon dioxide, trap heat within the earth's atmosphere instead of getting released. A steady

Eat the Human Condition Requires Us to
Words: 833 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Eat The human condition requires us to consume other living or inanimate objects in order to continue with our lives. This basic and simple habit of eating begins as a newborn as we eat what our parents feed us. The purpose of this essay is illustrate the phrase " you are what you eat," and look at the philosophical meanings of eating and consuming foods. This essay will explore different

Legal Research and Argument to Begin the
Words: 2020 Length: 7 Document Type: Case Study

Legal Research and Argument To begin the research for this case and the argument that follows, one must first examine the case and determine what is essential. It is assumed that the engineer was negligent because he should have known about the circular which advised that further structural support would be required for the type of building he was constructing. It is not enough to rely upon 20 years-worth of experience

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now